Islamic Law

Islamic Law

Challenges related to protect of artificial intelligence' patent

Document Type : Original Article

Authors
Abdorreza Alizadeh 1
Mahsa Tadayon sadi 2
Kazem Fouladi qale 3
1 Associate Professor of Private Law and Director of Private Law Department Faculty of Farabi Campus in University of Tehran
2 PHD student in private law of Farabi campus in university of Tehran
3 Scientific assistant of engineer college of Farabi University
Abstract
Artificial intelligence is a system which could act similar to human intelligent behaviour, comprehend complex situations, simulate thinking process, gain science, have argument of solving problem and at least make a new product. Sometimes human use this system for making her patent. sometimes it, independently makes a patent; a patent which if created by an human, supported in patent law. The problem is that, if artificial intelligence play a rol in creating a patent, as an instrument or independently, is it supportable or not? If yes, who is the rightholder? In this paper, we accede to in expressing – analytical approach, user of artificial intelligence is the rightholder at first assumption. But in second, the ownership is for public.
Keywords
Artificial intelligenc
algorithm
patent law
patent
PSA

Subjects

  1. Abbot, R.; »I think, therefore I invent: creative computers and the future of Patent Law«; Boston College Law Review, 2016, Vol. 57, Issue. 4
  2. Adewole, Ayodele A., International intellectual property system an the challenge fo artificial and monkey intelligence, 2019, 1(2) IRLJ 183
  3. Banterle, Francesco, Ownership of inventions created by Artificial Intelligence, 2018, AIDA
  4. Bently, L. et al; Intellectual property, 5th ed, OUP, 2018
  5. Bonadio, E., McDonagh, L.; »Artificial intelligence as producer and consumer of copyright works: Evaluating the consequences of algorithmic creativity«, IPQ, 2020
  6. Bosher, H., Gurgula, O., Stokes, S., Wang, F., Westenberger, P.; »WIPO impact on artificial intelligence on IP policy response from Brunel university London«; Law school and center for artificial intelligence, 2019
  7. Bridy, A.; »Coding creativity: Copyright and the artificially intelligent author«, STLR, 2012
  8. Brown, N.I.; »Artificial authors: Acase for copyright in computerـgenerated works«, Colum Sci & Tech L Rev, 2018
  9. Bruce G., B and Thomas E., H.; »Some speculation about artificial intelligence and legal reasoning«; Standard Law Review, vol 23, No 1, 1970. Pp.40ـ62
  10. Cattoor, S., et al; »Inventorship of AI made inventions«; IRDI, 2020
  11. Fraser, E.; »Computers as inventors – Legal and Policy implications of Artificial intelligence on Patent Law«; 13(3) SCRPTed, 2016
  12. Gabison, G. A.; »Who holds the right to exclude for Machine Work Products?«, IPQ, 2020
  13. Harmon, R. L.; »Harmon on patents«, BlackـLetter Law and Commentary(BNA books), 2007
  14. Hedrick, S. F.; »I think, therefore Icreate: Claiming copyright in the outputs of algorithms«; NYU Journal of Intell Prop & Ent Law, 2019
  15. Higgins, B.; »The role of explainable Artificial intelligence in Patent Law«; Intell Prop & Tech LJ, 2019
  16. Kaminski, M. E.; »Authorship, disrupted: AI authors in copyright and first amendment law«; UCD L Rev, 2017
  17. Keats, J.; »John Koza has built an invention machine«; Popular science, 2006
  18. Khoury, A. H.; »Intellectual property rights for Hubot: On the legal implications of humanـlike robots as innovators and creators«; Cardoz Arts & Ent LI, 2017
  19. McCutcheon, J.; »The vanishing author in computerـgeneratedworks: A critical analysis of recent Australian Case Law«; Melb U L Rev, 2013
  20. Samuelson, P.; »Allocating ownership rights in computerـgenerated works«; U Pitt L Rev, 1986
  21. Schuster, W. M.; »Artificial Intelligence and Patent ownership«; Wash & Lee L Rev, 2018
  22. Shemtov, N.; »A Study on inventorship in inventions involving AI activity«; EPO, 2019
  23. Stuart J., R. & Norving, P; »Artificial Intelligence : A Modern Approach«; 2003
  24. Vanherpe, J.; »AI and IP – A Tale of two acronyms«; 2020
  25. Vertisky, L.; »Thinking machines and Patent Law in Barfiald et al(eds)«; Research Handbook on the Law of Artificail Intelligence(Edward Elgar), 2018
  26. YaniskyـRavid Sh. And Liu, X.; »When artificial Intelligence systems produce inventions: An alternative model for patent law at the 3A Era«; Cardozo L Rev, 2018
  27. ـ; »Artificial Intelligence and the law: A futuristic legal system«; KMNP LAW, 2016